Support wanes for trade treaties
More Oregonians see foreign trade as a threat to the economy, polls show
Support for international trade slipped in Oregon while the major candidates for president criticized the Trans-Pacific Partnership agreement that Congress may consider later this year.
According to two polls conducted by Portland firm DHM Research, the percentage of Oregonians who believe foreign trade is more of an opportunity for economic growth dropped from 65 percent in March 2014 to 53 percent in April 2016.
During that time, the percentage of Oregonians who believe trade is more of a threat to the economy increased from 19 percent to 36 percent.
Our polling data reveal that Oregonians are less certain that international trade is a good deal for our state and our country in 2016 than they were two years prior, said DHM Researchs Adam Davis.
Waning support for international trade is of great interest to some businesses in Yamhill County and in the Newberg area because a number of industries – including wine, Christmas trees and hazelnuts – are heavily dependent on trade with other countries.
The drop in support followed repeated attacks on international trade treaties by Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump and Democratic presidential candidates Bernie Sanders and Hillary Clinton. All three candidates came out against the TPP, even though Clinton had previously called it the gold standard of such treaties.
The seemingly 24-7 coverage of Trump and Sanders this past year has taken its toll on public understanding and appreciation of the benefits of trade, Davis said. Its been a constant drum beat of Americans losing jobs and big companies being the only beneficiaries of policies like the Trans-Pacific Partnership.
Doug Badger, executive director of the Pacific Northwest International Trade Association, decries the criticisms. Although Trump, Sanders and to a lesser extent Clinton have all claimed such treaties have reduced the number of American jobs, Badger said the opposite is true, especially in Oregon.
Trade is creating jobs in the country and the region, which is especially dependent on trade. And they are good-paying jobs, said Badger, whose organization is aligned with the Portland Business Alliance and is pushing for approval of the TPP.
Badger notes that support for international trade is still above 50 percent in Oregon, which he said is a good thing. But he worries the criticisms by the presidential candidates will make it harder to win approval of the TPP and future trade agreements.
The politicians are saying one thing but the economy is saying another when it comes to trade, he said.
Davis agrees theres little public understanding of the benefits of trade.
Like we see in our research about public understanding of the basics of governance and public finance, theres a great deal of ignorance about international trade. And the Trans-Pacific Partnership agreement? You got to be kidding; theres next to no facts-based understanding of what it is and how it affects Oregons economy positively or negatively, Davis said.
TPP opponent Michael Shannon of the Oregon Fair Trade Campaign argues that just the opposite I true.
The public isnt responding to the politicians, the politicians are responding to the public, Shannon said.
People are tired of stagnant wages and increasing inequality, and previous trade deals have shipped good paying jobs with benefits overseas, said Shannon, whose organization includes labor, environmental and social justice organizations.
Davis confirms his companys polls are finding deep public dissatisfaction with the economy.
Nearly half of Oregonians believe that America has gotten the short end of the stick, perhaps in a nod of agreement with Trump and Sanders about the exportation of manufacturing and other blue-collar jobs that once served as the backbone of our economy. Many of these same people are not considering, because theyre not aware, the benefits of international trade such as lower prices and the availability of a wider range of goods and services, he said.
A 2013 study by the Value of Jobs Coalition found that $20 billion worth of Oregon goods and services were exported in 2012. There were 490,000 jobs tied directly or indirectly to international trade that year, up 20,000 from 2010. And the amount of Oregons trade-related employment grew 7.5 times faster than total employment between 2004 and 2011, said the study, which was supported by such business groups as the Portland Business Alliance and the Port of Portland.
The TPP is an agreement between the United States, Canada, Japan, Australia, Brunei, Chile, Malaysia, Mexico, New Zealand, Peru, Singapore and Vietnam. According to Badger, seven of Oregons top 11 export markets were on this list in 2015, and they accounted for nearly half of all of Oregons export value that year.
The export of Oregon goods and services will only increase if we can reform the rules and reduce the tariffs with our major trading partners, Badger said.
Shannon counters that the biggest companies, such as Nike, benefit most from such deals, not average workers.
Because of the political climate, some observers believe Obama will ask the lame-duck session of Congress to approve the TPP after the November general election.